Proctor Spars

Home Forums Development & Design Rigs & Sails Proctor Spars

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #5981
    krystalcrooks90
    Participant

    Has anyone bought or used the mast or boom sections from Proctor in WA?
    How do they compare to the other manufacturers?

    Thanks,

    Chris.

    #7029
    dulciechristense
    Participant

    According to the details on the Binks Marine page Proctor do not have a section that matches our measurement requirements. I strongly advise don’t even think about it!

    MRS

    #7030
    krystalcrooks90
    Participant

    Thanks Mike,

    On this page I got the impression they had class allowable spars:

    http://www.binksonline.com.au/products-sabre.asp

    UPDATE

    I have checked with Proctor that the sections are 65-67mm by 49-51mm amd this is class spec.

    🙄

    #7031
    dulciechristense
    Participant

    Yep! That is our standard section!
    It is an Alcan section not a Proctor!
    Worth checking price with John Dixon at Iecon – he is much cheaper (about $100) but not anodised and if you’re in Vic you can pick it up saving freight.

    #7032
    heymacaulay
    Keymaster

    Proctor are out of the UK as well.

    Binks are the importer and Aust Distributor

    #7033
    syreetanajera
    Participant

    Could someone clarify the ‘standard’ boom mentioned above.

    The rules state:

    7.1 a. The boom shall be made from constant section round aluminium alloy 50mm diameter x 1.5, 2 or 3mm

    Chriso says:

    I have checked with Proctor that the sections are 65-67mm by 49-51mm amd this is class spec.

    Mike then says:

    Yep! That is our standard section!

    So,… is the Binksmarine ‘Proctor/Selden’ boom class legal or not?

    If it isn’t who does sell anodised tube suitable for a Sabre boom?

    UPDATE:

    I’ve just called Binks & spoken to them (a sabre sailor as well so she knew what she was talking about!). The section they sell is circular, not as Chriso stated above.

    #7034
    dulciechristense
    Participant

    I was of the understanding Chriso & I were discussing the mast section.

    The mast & boom are distinctly different extrusions; the boom section being a simple tube in three optional wall thicknesse as specified in Rule 7.1(a), the mast is an oval shape as specified in measurements 94 & 95.

    To my knowledge there is now only one legal mast section made in Australia now, that is the Comalco E11466. I am not aware of any other section that fits our parameters and would be interested to hear about any options people may know of.

    I know of two Sabre mast suppliers in Victoria; John Dixon at Iecon in Bayswater stocks masts (he currently has some anodised mast sections) and also sells boom sections in at least two thicknesses; Bob Keeley in Moorabbin has masts, I’m not sure if he has booms.

    Boom sections are also available from aluminium suppliers but would be 6 metres or so in length.

    Unless the Binks mast is a renamed Comalco extrusion it may not comply. The SA measurer may be familiar with the legality of the Binks section.

    #7035
    heymacaulay
    Keymaster

    OK, Here we go.

    Just to save all the confusion, I did something anyone else could have done right from the start and rang Binks Directly and verified the facts.

    1. The Sabre Mast Section at Binks is a Alcan K64621 (formally Comalco E11466 – but it is the same section). It just happens to appear in the Proctor Spars Section of their website, as that is where all the Spars, regardless of origin, appear – even the Goldspar Sections. This, if I understood correctly, is because that part of the business is called the Proctor Spar Shop.

    2. The Boom section is a standard 50mm straight tube, annodised. This type of section is also available, quite often heaps cheaper at any good Steel/Aluminium Supplies business; you can often get a 6m section for the same price as some Yachting Shops charge for a section long enough for a Sabre boom. Again – Ring around.

    3. If the guy in Moorabbin is the guy I spoke to last year when I was still living in WA. He had some interesting info on current Sabre/125/Pacer/JD Mast Sections. Evidently, there is a batch that was made up by the 125 Assoc, that a lot of places took on as stock, which were made of a different grade of aluminium to the batch he had made.

    He went up a grade of aluminium to get a stiffer, stronger section, but still used the same die and therefore the same shaped section, as a lot of people were having trouble with the 125 Assoc batch sections – They were bending to easily.

    Problem, His sections as a result are a bit more expensive – about $50 from memory, though may have been a bit more or less.

    Again, ring him and check.

    Hope this solves all the questions. The Mast sections are also readily available at Boating Hardware in O’Connor (WA).

    Regards . . .

    #7036
    krystalcrooks90
    Participant

    Thanks Peter and Mike.

    I have also checkd local suppliers and have come to the conclusion that the ability to hike for an extra 2 minutes going up hill will be worth more than paying top rates for spars when its all much of a muchness.

    See you both at Elwood for the states.

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
  • The forum ‘Rigs & Sails’ is closed to new topics and replies.